On 11 November 2026, the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) released draft Practical Compliance Guideline PCG 2026/D5 Back-to-back CGT rollovers and Part IVA of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Draft PCG).
The Draft PCG provides guidance on the ATO’s view of the application of Part IVA to arrangements involving back-to-back CGT rollovers. For the purposes of the Draft PCG, back-to-back CGT rollovers are arrangements involving successive CGT events affecting the same asset (or its replacement asset), where a CGT rollover is chosen in relation to two or more of these CGT events. It outlines factors that are relevant to the ATO’s treatment of such arrangements as either ‘lower risk’ or ‘higher risk’, which will in turn, guide the ATO’s application of compliance resources to reviewing these types of arrangements.
The Draft PCG is currently open for consultation, with comments due by 11 December 2026, a relatively short consultation window considering the release of the Draft PCG has been long awaited.
Key takeaways
- Importance of Commerciality: Consistent with the High Court in Commissioner of Taxation v Merchant; Merchant v Commissioner of Taxation [2026] HCA 39 (Merchant) the ATO is focused on restructures that include one or more steps that are (predominantly) explained by the tax outcome.
- Interdependence is the gateway risk factor: The ATO considers that back-to-back CGT rollovers are interdependent if they are executed as part of a single agreement, overarching strategy or coordinated undertaking – including where one transaction is conditional on another. Interdependent arrangements are considered to be ‘higher risk’ where they include an intermediate step that serves no or limited apparent purpose beyond enabling a future rollover and at least one other additional element is present (including the disregarding of a capital gain, increase of a capital loss or reduction of future capital gain or an increase in capital allowance deductions).
- Repercussions of AusNet: The inclusion in example 3 of the Draft PCG of the interposition of a top company, claim of Division 615 rollover relief (which was the issue considered in AusNet Services Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2025) 308 FCR 206 (AusNet)) and availability of subsequent consolidation uplifts, is unsurprising given the ATO’s view of the AusNet transaction and their comments on the need for guidance on the back of the decisions.
- Retrospective application. When finalised, the Draft PCG is proposed to apply to past arrangements. Historical restructures undertaken by corporate groups, particularly those still within the ATO’s 4-year amendment period, should be reviewed.
- Evidence is essential. The Draft PCG lists the contemporaneous documentation the ATO expects, such as board minutes, step plans, valuations and transaction documents.
Overview of the Draft PCG
The Draft PCG has been on the ATO’s Advice under development program for some time and was proposed for release in late 2025. It is possible that the timing was influenced in part by the taxpayer’s application for special leave to appeal the decision in AusNet to the High Court, which was refused on 7 August 2025 and the recent proposed changes announced in the Federal Budget which may result in a number of restructures.
The Draft PCG is concerned with arrangements where the initial CGT rollover forms an intermediate step that serves no (or limited) apparent purpose beyond creating the circumstances in which a subsequent rollover can be accessed, in order to defer, reduce or eliminate capital gains or create other tax advantages.
The Draft PCG provides a risk framework for determining where the ATO will use its compliance resources to review arrangements. The ATO has identified that it will prioritise “higher risk” arrangements and be less likely to review “lower risk” arrangements (save for confirming that an arrangement is within the lower risk category and that there are no other relevant risk factors which should be considered).
The Draft PCG’s risk framework turns on the following two key questions:
- Are the rollovers interdependent?
- What is the commercial or practical utility of each step and is there an intermediate step that serves no or limited apparent purpose beyond enabling the further rollover to be applied?
The table below summarises the two key risk categories.
|
|
Higher risk
|
Lower risk
|
|
Interdependent transactions
|
Interdependent rollovers may include those where:
|
The transactions are not part of a single agreement, strategy or coordinated undertaking, and neither transaction is conditional on the execution of the other. |
|
Commercial or practical utility of each step
|
One or more steps in the arrangement do not appear to contribute to the commercial objective and appear to only be explicable by reference to the tax consequences achieved. |
All individual steps involved in the arrangement demonstrably contribute to the commercial objective sought, beyond any tax outcomes achieved. |
|
Tax consequences that affect the risk categories
|
The most likely tax benefits arising from broader schemes involving a back-to-back rollover with an intermediate step that has no or limited apparent purpose beyond enabling the second rollover, include:
|
The PCG is silent on this point, however where the tax benefits identified in paragraphs (a) to (c) are not prevalent, it can be deduced that the arrangement is more likely to be a lower risk arrangement. |
Observations
- Importance of commerciality: The Draft PCG identifies there is a higher risk where an arrangement involves an intermediate step that serves “no or limited apparent purpose” beyond facilitating the subsequent rollover. This is consistent with recent the High Court decision in Merchant (see the Mallesons Alert), where the High Court found that the transaction achieved “no other meaningful or realistic commercial objective”, other than obtaining the tax benefit. In this context, and as identified in the Draft PCG, documentation of the commercial purpose of each step in arrangements involving the back-to-back rollovers will be critical.
- Related-party restructures remain in focus: Examples 2 and 4 involve commonly controlled entities. This is consistent with the Commissioner’s recent focus on internal restructures preceding sales and is an expected outcome, with rollovers being a common feature of internal restructures (see the Mallesons Alert).
- Interdependence is a gateway factor: The description of ‘interdependent’ arrangements in the Draft PCG, specifically, transactions executed “as part of a single arrangement, overarching strategy or coordinated undertaking” or where one transaction is conditional on the other is a key element of an arrangement classified as ‘high risk’. The broad interpretation of ‘interdependence’ is consistent with the Full Federal Court’s description of ‘interdependent’ transactions in AusNet, where it was held that the relevant schemes were separate but interdependent and ‘interdependent’ was interpreted broadly, to include arrangements where the operation of one contract is related to the operation of the other.
- Interaction with consolidation: Similar to the transaction described in example 3, the transaction considered by the Full Federal Court in AusNet involved the interposition of a top company, claim of Division 615 rollover relief (the availability of which was the issue considered in AusNet) and the availability of cost base step-ups as a consequence of consolidation. Whilst the fact pattern considered in AusNet is unusual (i.e. the taxpayer alleging it improperly claimed rollover relief), the ATO’s focus in the Draft PCG on tax benefits arising from back-to-back rollovers and consolidation is unsurprising, particularly given the ATO’s objection to the outcome sought by AusNet and the Full Federal Court’s decision in support of the ATO.
- Retrospectivity: The Draft PCG provides that the Guideline is proposed to apply to arrangements entered into before and after its date of issue. Noting the ATO has a 4-year period to amend assessments, taxpayers should review historical restructures and arrangements involving a back-to-back rollover and ensure that accurate records detailing the commercial justification for these transactions are retained.
- Relevance for groups involving discretionary trust structures: The Draft PCG is particularly relevant for discretionary trust groups. Following recent legislative changes to the taxation of discretionary trusts (see the Mallesons Alert), groups may consider restructuring, for example trust to company under Subdivision 124-N or Subdivision 122-A followed by further steps. Advisers should be aware of the Draft PCG in this context.
Where to next?
Comments on the Draft PCG are due by 11 December 2026. In the meantime, given the proposed retrospective application of the guidance, taxpayers should review historical restructures that may be caught by the “higher risk” examples, consider any plans or current restructures that may be caught by the Draft PCG and retain documentation to support the commercial rationale for any back-to-back rollovers.
Please contact the Mallesons Tax team if you would like to discuss how the Draft PCG may affect you.


