Insight,

Under Stress: Mental Health Claims and the Opportunity for Regulatory Reform in Australian Life Insurance

AU | EN
Current site :    AU   |   EN
Australia
Singapore

Mental health-related claims account for one in three total and permanent disability (TPD) claims paid under group life policies in Australia, and among claimants in their thirties have increased by more than 700 per cent over the past decade.[1] It is widely acknowledged that the increase in mental health-related TPD claims is putting the life insurance industry under significant financial and operational stress, with the risk of multi-national life insurers withdrawing from the Australian market. Fewer participants would mean less competition, with consequences for the pricing, terms and availability of life insurance cover in Australia. APRA and ASIC have convened a roundtable with major superannuation funds and life insurers on 25 November 2026, reportedly to avoid such a worst-case scenario.

The physical and psychological benefits to an injured worker returning to the workforce are well documented.[2] In 2017, Monash University published ‘The Cross Sector Project: Mapping Australian Systems of Income Support for People with Health-Related Work Incapacity’ (Cross Sector Project Report).[3] In 2025, the Council of Australian Life Insurers (CALI) commissioned an update to the Cross Sector Project Report (Cross Sector Project Update).[4] The Cross Sector Project Report identified several opportunities to improve work and health outcomes, including early intervention and the ‘potential to consider product and benefit design to reduce gaps in support and better encourage return to work’. The Cross Sector Project Update similarly identified key systemic issues as including ‘limited access to treatment’ and ‘missed opportunities for early intervention.’

However, the interaction of the Life Insurance Act 1995 (Cth) (Life Act), the Health Insurance Act 1973 (Cth) (HI Act), the Private Health Insurance Act 2007 (Cth) (PHI Act), and the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth) (SIS Act) currently prevents life insurers from funding claimant treatment.

This article sets out the legislative barriers, the cross-system interactions that amplify them, and potential regulatory reform, drawing on international models and recent Australian evidence of successful early intervention.

The Regulatory Framework

The Australian life insurance system operates within a multi-layered regulatory architecture that was not designed with mental health rehabilitation in mind.

Life Act

Section 234 of the Life Act prohibits a life company from carrying on mixed insurance business, that is, insurance business other than life insurance business. Section 9A expressly provides that a contract entered into in the course of carrying on health insurance business is not a continuous disability policy, and therefore is not a life policy and is not life insurance business. And, whilst section 12A gives APRA the power to declare other business as life insurance business, it expressly provides that APRA may not make such a declaration in respect of health insurance business.

Health Insurance Legislation

The PHI Act and the Private Health Insurance (Health Insurance Business) Rules 2013 (PHI Business Rules) define what constitutes ‘health insurance business’ and therefore determine the boundary between permissible life insurance benefits and health insurance business.

Section 126 of the HI Act then prohibits private health insurance covering a liability to pay a medical expense where a corresponding Medicare benefit is payable.

SIS Act

The SIS Act requires a superannuation fund to be maintained by a superannuation trustee solely for a core purpose such as to provide retirement benefits and death benefits. In addition to one or more core purposes, a superannuation trustee may also maintain the superannuation fund for an ancillary purpose such as the provision of benefits after ceasing work due to ill-health. The sole purpose test can at times be perceived to be a barrier to the provision of support to keep members in the workforce.

The conditions of release in the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994 (Cth) (SIS Regulations) can restrict the benefits that are payable on temporary incapacity to a non-commutable income stream, the purpose of which is income replacement and is limited in time to the period of incapacity. In addition, the timing of conditions of release (eg cessation of employment) may mean that mental health support is provided later than is optimal to minimise the impact on the insured’s employment.

The best financial interests duty of a superannuation trustee, along with the requirement to ensure that insurance does not inappropriately erode the retirement income of beneficiaries, appropriately focuses superannuation trustees on the premiums that are payable for insurance cover. This focus has been heightened by several class actions concerning premiums that were payable by superannuation trustees. Rising TPD claims are now placing upward pressure on group insurance premiums, which are deducted from members’ accounts and, compounded over a working life, may materially erode members’ retirement balances. However, superannuation trustees must also consider their duty to be fair to members within a class of insured members, which requires a superannuation trustee to consider the sustainability of premiums over both the short and the longer term.

The Restriction on Life Insurers Providing Health Services

The interaction of the Life Act, the PHI Act, the PHI Business Rules and the HI Act produces a significant structural constraint - life insurers are not permitted to provide a benefit to a claimant for treatment costs where the treatment constitutes hospital treatment or general treatment within the meaning of the private health insurance legislation, or where a corresponding Medicare benefit is payable.

The practical consequence is that any gap in treatment costs after reimbursement from Medicare or a private health insurer cannot be funded by a life insurer and must be met directly by the individual claimant, unless it is covered by another statutory scheme such as workers compensation insurance.

APRA itself has recognised that:

‘there are genuine constraints around product design. The industry has highlighted legislative restrictions where APRA does not hold the levers. We cannot change those settings, but we can help facilitate dialogue with government where needed.’[5]

The Interaction with Superannuation

The superannuation system amplifies the structural difficulties.

The sole purpose test is focused on the provision of benefits on or after ceasing work due to retirement, death or ill-health. Then, if a person has temporarily ceased work, their benefit is limited to an income stream for the purpose of continuing their income while they are temporarily incapacitated. The focus is ‘after the event’ benefits rather than preventative support that could prolong a person’s period of work and increase productivity.

In addition, generally, a superannuation trustee cannot provide an insured benefit unless the insured event is consistent with the death, terminal medical condition, permanent incapacity or temporary incapacity conditions of release.[6] Any support provided must be carefully structured to avoid breaching this rule.

The Interaction with Workers’ Compensation

Workers’ compensation schemes and life insurers share a fundamental objective - supporting an injured person’s recovery and, where possible, return to work. Workers’ compensation schemes are structured around rehabilitation and return to work. Life insurers likewise have financial and social interests in claimant recovery, rather than in the permanence of disability.

The difficulty arises because the applicable legal frameworks and product structures generate different evidentiary requirements and incentives. In particular, TPD insurance requires the claimant to establish permanence (in summary, that they will not work again in their own or a reasonably suited occupation), while workers’ compensation processes generally encourage rehabilitation and progressive return to work.

These differences can produce conflicting motivations for claimants with mental health conditions. A person receiving workers’ compensation support may be encouraged to engage in treatment, rehabilitation, and a progressive return to work, while a concurrent TPD claim may require evidence that the incapacity is permanent.

The Cross Sector Project Report found that 30% to 50% of people making life insurance TPD claims had previously been in contact with a workers’ or motor vehicle accident compensation system during the same episode of work incapacity. This demonstrates that TPD claimants may previously have had interactions with another compensation system, reinforcing the need for clear hand-offs, shared information and rehabilitation that begins before a life insurance claim is finalised.

Recent legislative reforms reflect the fiscal pressure. The Actuaries Institute noted in its 2026 submission to the Life Insurance Code of Practice Review that ‘recent workers’ compensation reforms in Victoria and New South Wales - including increases to whole-person impairment thresholds for psychological claims - illustrate that, despite being contentious, governments have considered such changes necessary to restore financial sustainability.’[7] The Cross Sector Project Update likewise notes that Victoria and New South Wales have made changes affecting eligibility for claims related to mental health conditions. Recently legislation has been introduced into the Queensland Parliament so that for workers’ compensation involving psychological or psychiatric injuries, employment would have to be the major significant contributing factor rather than a significant contributing factor. One anticipated impact of the tightening of workers’ compensation in Queensland, NSW and Victoria is that people unable to work because of their mental health but ineligible for workers’ compensation will require income support from other parts of the ecosystem, including life insurance or social security.

The Interaction with Private Health Insurance

The interface between life insurance and private health insurance compounds the treatment-funding gap. Under section 126 of the HI Act, private health insurers and others are prohibited from covering services attracting a Medicare benefit, and their coverage of mental health services is typically limited to hospital-admitted psychiatric care and a narrow range of allied health services.

For a life insurance claimant with a mental health condition, this creates a coverage gap. Medicare provides a limited number of subsidised psychology sessions (currently 10 per calendar year under a Mental Health Treatment Plan). Private health insurance may contribute towards some additional allied health sessions, such as psychologist sessions, under extras cover, depending on the policy, but it cannot cover out-of-hospital medical services, such as psychiatrist consultations. Once those entitlements are exhausted, the individual bears the full cost of ongoing treatment.

Given the rising cost of mental health related claims, private health insurers are seeking reform for the same reason as life insurers: to fund earlier intervention.

Life Insurance Code of Practice Review

The 2026 Independent Review of the Life Insurance Code of Practice recommended that:

  1. the Code prohibit total exclusions of cover for mental health conditions in standard form contracts;
  2. any standard form limitation be supported by documented actuarial or statistical data and reviewed at least every three years;
  3. CALI develop guidance on fair and transparent cover, including sustainable product design; and
  4. insurers better explain underwriting decisions and mental health disclosure requirements, supported by a plain-English ‘Consumer Guide to Life Insurance and Mental Health’.

On 30 September 2026, CALI released its response to the final report of the 2026 Independent Review of the Life Insurance Code of Practice. CALI has proposed that standard form disability contracts should not automatically exclude cover for all mental health conditions, but that this should not prevent benefit design features for mental health cover (such as caps, eligibility criteria, waiting periods or maximum sum insured limits), customer choice to modify cover, or alternative terms following individual underwriting. CALI has referred the data, product review and guidance recommendations to a mental health priority workstream expected to conclude in the first half of 2027.

This position raises the bar for life insurers that are CALI members beyond the standard imposed by the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth). This poses some important questions about the sustainability of the provision of life insurance cover in Australia (and, at the very least, the premium for which that cover is provided) in the face of rising mental health claims, with life insurers being legislatively hampered in supporting the recovery of those claimants. Superannuation trustees will also have to consider whether group insurance premiums are inappropriately eroding the retirement incomes of beneficiaries. Conversely, if cover for mental health conditions is limited or becomes unavailable, members who are unable to work may increasingly seek early release of their superannuation (for example, on compassionate or severe financial hardship grounds) to meet treatment and living costs, further depleting their retirement savings.

International Models

Several jurisdictions have implemented integrated approaches to mental health, employment, and disability.

New Zealand: The ACC Single-Funder Model

New Zealand’s Accident Compensation Corporation provides a universal, no-fault model for covered mental injuries, including those arising from physical injury, work-related traumatic events, and sexual violence. ACC provides counselling, therapy, psychiatric assessments, day programmes, and residential rehabilitation through one coordinated system. The limitation of the ACC model is its exclusion of gradual-process mental injuries such as those arising from workplace bullying or cumulative stress.

The Netherlands: The Gatekeeper Model

The Dutch approach places direct financial responsibility on employers for sickness absence benefits for the first two years. Treating physicians have been prohibited from writing sick notes since 1993, thereby separating clinical care from disability assessment. Since 2008, government-funded mental health specialists have been embedded within GP practices. This model has produced significant reductions in both sickness absence duration and new disability claims.

Denmark: Cross-Sectoral Coordination

Denmark’s 10-year action plan for psychiatry and mental health, adopted in 2022, establishes binding cooperation agreements across health, social care, education, and employment authorities. Municipal job centres operate multidisciplinary rehabilitation teams that integrate health, labour market, social services, and education sectors. Permanent contact persons serve as coordinators across all sectors, providing continuity of support for individuals with mental health conditions.

United Kingdom: IAPT and Integrated Employment Services

The United Kingdom’s Improving Access to Psychological Therapies (IAPT) programme embeds employment advisers within mental health treatment services. The co-location model ensures that a person receiving psychological treatment simultaneously receives employment support—addressing the OECD’s finding that mental health treatment alone does not improve employment outcomes. The complementary Health and Work Service provides occupational health assessments and return-to-work planning.

OECD Recommendations

The OECD’s 2014 Working Paper No. 161 and 2015 Council Recommendation on Integrated Mental Health, Skills and Work Policy concluded that more integrated provision within each sector is the easiest and most cost-effective approach to improving outcomes. The key recommendations include embedding employment advice within the health system and psychological expertise within employment services. The OECD found that integration is beneficial for both severe and common mental disorders.

Potential Reform

The international evidence suggests several potential reform pathways for Australia.

Legislative reform to permit life insurer-funded rehabilitation.

The most direct pathway would remove the regulatory barriers preventing life insurers from funding treatment and rehabilitation for claimants under continuous disability policies. Consistent with opportunities identified in the Cross Sector Project, reform should also consider providing access to rehabilitation during the waiting period of a life insurance claim and early identification of people with complex health conditions or risk factors for delayed recovery. This would align financial incentives with therapeutic outcomes as the party bearing the cost of permanence would be empowered to invest in recovery.

Because private health insurers are now pressing for parallel changes to fund non-hospital mental health care, any review of the private health insurance framework presents an opportunity to consider the position of life insurers at the same time, rather than in isolation.

The PHI Act expanded hospital cover to cover out-of-hospital services that substitute for or prevent hospitalisation and which can be safely delivered outside of a hospital setting. This change was described as removing ‘a significant impediment to the development of flexible health care products that better reflect contemporary clinical practice and meet consumers’ growing needs and expectations.’[8] The growing need in the Australian community for mental health support suggests that it may be time to remove the legislative barriers for both life insurers and private health insurers to provide such support.

Legislative reform to clarify that superannuation funds can flow through life insurer-funded rehabilitation

The superannuation industry could also assist in providing mental health wellness support for their members.

There is a legislative pathway to remove the barriers.

  1. Sole purpose test: APRA can approve an ‘ancillary benefit’ for the sole purpose test.[9] It has done so previously so that benefits that are paid consistently with Part 6 of the SIS Regulations are an ancillary benefit. That instrument could be amended to clarify that life insurer funded rehabilitation benefits are consistent with the sole purpose test under section 62(1)(b)(v) of the SIS Act.[10]
  2. Conditions of release: If APRA issues such an instrument, it can also make a condition of release and impose any cashing restrictions on that condition of release.[11]
  3. SIS Regulation 4.07D: This is an operating standard that APRA is empowered to modify and could do so to remove concerns that the provision of wellness support would be an insured benefit that cannot be provided. This could be done by adding to the conditions of release listed as circumstances in which an insured benefit can be paid to include the expanded condition of release that is referred to above.

Cross-sectoral coordination frameworks

Drawing on the Danish model and the Cross Sector Project Update, binding cooperation agreements between life insurers, workers’ compensation authorities, health services and relevant government agencies could reduce duplication and ensure continuity of support. The Cross Sector Project also identified substantial gaps in data capture, standardisation and reporting across systems. Closing those gaps would improve accountability, enable better measurement of movement between systems and support evaluation of early-intervention programs.

Separation of clinical care from disability assessment

The Dutch model of separating the treating relationship from the fitness-for-work assessment removes the conflict inherent in the current Australian system, where treating practitioners may be asked to provide evidence supporting either recovery (for workers’ compensation) or permanence (for TPD).

Integrated employment support within treatment pathways

The IAPT model demonstrates that embedding employment advisers within mental health services produces superior outcomes to sequential treatment-then-employment approaches. The Comcare Your Futures program, highlighted in the Cross Sector Project Update, provides Australian evidence that targeted support can work: it focused on injured workers with psychological injuries and long-term claims and showed that even workers who had spent years away from work could return to employment and improve their mental health with the right support at the right time. Life insurers could, subject to legislative reform, fund such integrated services as part of claims management. This may also assist Australia’s productivity problem.

Product redesign within the superannuation framework

Together, the Actuaries Institute’s support for permitting mental health limitations in standard form policies, APRA’s sustainability concerns and CALI’s response to the Life Code review, which would permit caps, waiting periods, eligibility criteria and sum insured limits on mental health cover short of a total exclusion, suggest scope to redesign products by replacing binary TPD definitions with graduated support models better suited to the episodic nature of mental health conditions. The outcome of CALI’s mental health priority workstream will be critical in defining that scope.

Legislative reform requires coordination across multiple Commonwealth statutes and potentially state workers’ compensation legislation. Product redesign must navigate the superannuation’s sole purpose test, conditions of release and the best financial interests duty, which appropriately protects members’ financial interests, as well as potential discrimination concerns. Cross-sectoral coordination requires institutional willingness across regulators with different mandates. Any reform would therefore need to address both immediate member protection and the longer-term sustainability of group insurance.

Conclusion

The Cross Sector Project Update captures the required response as ‘a coordinated approach, grounded in early intervention, clear accountability and a focus on recovery.’

Key priorities include engagement with APRA’s sustainability agenda and with CALI’s mental health and claims handling priority workstreams, which are expected to conclude in the first half of 2027 and will shape the next Life Insurance Code of Practice; monitoring and contributing to any legislative reform addressing the prohibition on life insurer-funded health services; and considering product design innovations that may be achievable within the existing framework while supporting broader structural reform required for long-term sustainability.

APRA Executive Director Jane Magill’s remarks to the Actuaries Summit, published 27 May 2026, based on data from the Council of Australian Life Insurers.

Waddell and Burton, Is Work Good for Your Health and Well-being? (2006). The authors were commissioned by the UK Department for Work and Pensions to conduct this independent review of the scientific evidence.

Collie, A., Iles, R. and Di Donato M.F, ‘The Cross Sector Project: Mapping Australian Systems of Income Support for People with Health Related Work Incapacity’, Insurance Work and Health Group, Faculty of Medicine Nursing and Health Sciences, Monash University (2017).

Volkov I and Iles R, ‘Cross Sector Project Update: Mapping Australia’s ecosystem of income supports’ (2025).

APRA Executive Director Jane Magill’s remarks to the Actuaries Summit, published 27 May 2026.

Regulation 4.07D of the SIS Regulations.

Actuaries Institute's submission to the Life Insurance Code of Practice Review – Interim Report Response, dated 12 May 2026.

Paragraph 1.13 of the Senate Standing Committee on Community Affairs report into Private Health Insurance Bill 2006 and six related bills, February 2007

Section 62(1)(b)(v) of the SIS Act.

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act approval of provision of benefits (No.1) 2007.

Item 114 of Schedule 1 to the SIS Regulations.

Reference

  • [1]

    APRA Executive Director Jane Magill’s remarks to the Actuaries Summit, published 27 May 2026, based on data from the Council of Australian Life Insurers.

  • [2]

    Waddell and Burton, Is Work Good for Your Health and Well-being? (2006). The authors were commissioned by the UK Department for Work and Pensions to conduct this independent review of the scientific evidence.

  • [3]

    Collie, A., Iles, R. and Di Donato M.F, ‘The Cross Sector Project: Mapping Australian Systems of Income Support for People with Health Related Work Incapacity’, Insurance Work and Health Group, Faculty of Medicine Nursing and Health Sciences, Monash University (2017).

  • [4]

    Volkov I and Iles R, ‘Cross Sector Project Update: Mapping Australia’s ecosystem of income supports’ (2025).

  • [5]

    APRA Executive Director Jane Magill’s remarks to the Actuaries Summit, published 27 May 2026.

  • [6]

    Regulation 4.07D of the SIS Regulations.

  • [7]

    Actuaries Institute's submission to the Life Insurance Code of Practice Review – Interim Report Response, dated 12 May 2026.

  • [8]

    Paragraph 1.13 of the Senate Standing Committee on Community Affairs report into Private Health Insurance Bill 2006 and six related bills, February 2007

  • [9]

    Section 62(1)(b)(v) of the SIS Act.

  • [10]

    Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act approval of provision of benefits (No.1) 2007.

  • [11]

    Item 114 of Schedule 1 to the SIS Regulations.

  • Show More
Latest Thinking
Insight
On 4 November 2026, the High Court of Australia handed down its decision in Commissioner of Taxation v Merchant; Merchant v Commissioner of Taxation [2026] HCA 39 (Merchant).

11 November 2026

Insight
On 6 November 2026, ASIC released simple consultation CS 68. CS 68 relates to the implementation of the statutory framework covered in our April 2026 update which introduces new Australian financial services licence (AFS licence) exemptions for foreign financial services providers (FFSPs).

10 November 2026

Insight
We explain the key elements of the UOMO and what it means for mobile network operators, LEO satellite operators, carriage service providers and mobile virtual network operators.

10 November 2026