Data centres are fast becoming one of the most significant sources of electricity demand in the market. New regulatory settings require that demand is to be met with power that is entirely renewable and firmed. Satisfying those requirements will call for billions of dollars of new generation and storage – and raises a fundamental commercial question: who is best placed to build, contract and manage that supply?
In this insight, which we have explored further in episode 9 of our Power Perspectives podcast, we look at the procurement models available to data centre operators, the trade-offs each involves and why energy retailers organically become the natural intermediaries.
We also consider what this means for investors, developers and financiers looking to capture the opportunity.
Key takeaways
- New requirements for new and firmed renewable energy supply will drive billions of dollars of investment in renewable generation and storage to support growing data centre demand.
- Operators have four principal procurement pathways, each with different trade-offs between cost, control, complexity and risk.
- Retailers are natural intermediaries, with the balance sheets, hedge books and expertise to package renewable generation and firming into a single product.
- Portfolio owners also have an opportunity to aggregate renewable and storage assets or develop separate green and firming products.
- The key question for data centre operators will be where to sit in the contracting chain and which party is best placed to carry data centre-specific risk.
The new requirements: 100% renewable and 100% firm
Data centre operators are facing an increasingly significant energy procurement challenge. The Commonwealth has asked the Australian Energy Market Commission (AEMC) to amend the National Electricity Rules to require larger data centres to demonstrate that their electricity demand is backed by new, firm supply in the same region (see our recent article outlining these changes here).
The “new and additional” element is critical. Operators cannot simply buy into the output of existing assets: the requirements are designed to drive the construction of new renewable projects alongside new battery storage or gas-fired capacity. For the larger facilities, the associated energy investment can run into the billions of dollars. That creates a significant opportunity across the energy sector, but also a procurement challenge that most data centre operators have not had to solve before.
Procurement models
Data centre operators have four main energy procurement options, each offering unique trade-offs in relation to cost, control and risk.
|
Model
|
Key advantages
|
Key challenges
|
|
Self-build (including co-located generation). |
Greater control over delivery and timing. |
Significant capital cost; operating capability; securing land and grid connection. |
|
Bilateral contracts with individual projects. |
Direct control over the portfolio mix. |
Complexity of matching volume and firming; residual exposures; management burden. |
|
Contracting with a large IPP for a portfolio of projects. |
Fewer counterparties; projects delivered to meet the data centre’s needs. |
Sizing demand and aligning project delivery with the data centre timetable. |
|
Retailer-managed package. |
Single counterparty; balance sheet and hedge book absorb complexity. |
Retailer premium. |
Self-build: control at a cost
Developing generation and firming capacity in-house – whether co-located with the data centre or elsewhere – has an obvious attraction. Delivery timing is often critical for data centre projects, and owning the energy supply gives an operator greater say over when that supply comes online.
But self-build raises two significant issues:
- Cost: It is easy to assume data centre operators have ready access to capital, but many will prefer to deploy that capital into their next facility rather than into the energy supply for their current one; and
- Capability: Developing and operating power infrastructure is complex, requires a different skill set and deep understanding of a nuanced regulatory environment.
In practice, only the largest data centre operators will likely consider self-build sources of power to be a viable option.
Bilateral contracting
An operator could instead build its own portfolio of contracts with individual projects – potentially four to six offtake arrangements covering a mix of wind, solar, gas and batteries. In theory, this preserves control over the portfolio mix. In practice, it is likely to prove too hard for most operators.
Data centre operators are already managing complex contracts with their own customers and delivering technically demanding infrastructure. Stitching together a portfolio that delivers 100% renewable and 100% firmed coverage – with the right volumes, shapes and timing – demands considerable time, money and specialist expertise.
The experience of corporate PPAs over the past five or six years is instructive. Many corporates pursuing 100% renewable targets entered into multiple PPAs, only to find they had contracted too much or too little, and had taken on exposures they were not equipped to manage. The lesson many drew was that, unless an organisation is in the business of running an electricity hedge book, that task is better left to a party whose business is packaging energy solutions. Unless managing its own power book delivers a genuine competitive advantage over its peers, a data centre operator is likely to reach the same conclusion.
Contracting with a portfolio IPP
A large independent power producer (IPP) can deliver a portfolio of projects to provide the contracts a data centre needs, reducing the number of counterparties. The operator does, however, retain significant risk: it must size its demand accurately and secure contracts that align with the delivery timetable of a large and complex project. Any mismatch between the IPP’s portfolio delivery and the data centre’s commissioning is a risk the operator must manage.
Generation platforms and managed funds that hold portfolios of renewable and storage assets – spanning different technologies and locations – may be able to mix and match those assets to fit a particular demand profile and offer a flexible, firmed product directly. Whoever can organise and orchestrate such an offering stands to earn a real premium.
The retailer-managed package
Given the prescriptive renewable and firming requirements, there is a strong case that supply to data centres should look to a party with a large hedge book, strong balance sheet and a wealth of expertise in Australia’s electricity markets. That points squarely to retailers.
For retailers prepared to develop a customisable, flexible product built on a portfolio of projects, this is a golden opportunity. For data centre operators, the decision ultimately comes down to price: pay the retailer’s premium, or back themselves to pursue one of the other procurement models outlined above.
The market may also not converge on a single product. Retailers and generation platforms may choose to supply only part of the requirement – for example, a renewable (“green”) product – leaving the data centre operator to address firming itself, such as through behind-the-meter batteries. A market with separate green and firm products, each supplied by the parties best placed to provide it, is a realistic prospect.
What this means for investors, developers and financiers
For equity investors seeking exposure to this opportunity in the power sector, a central question is where to sit in the contracting chain:
- Contracting directly with data centres: this brings direct exposure to the data centre project, its delivery risk and the long tail of obligations that comes with contracting on a head-to-head basis.
- Sitting behind the retailer: investors can instead supply the additional green and storage projects that retailers and portfolio players will need in order to sell firmed products to data centres, leaving the retailer to bundle and manage that exposure.
The right answer will depend on each investor’s appetite for data centre-specific risk, and on how quickly retailers and portfolio owners move to occupy the intermediary role. Developers and financiers will likewise need to assess how offtake arrangements are structured – and with whom – when evaluating the bankability of projects underpinned by data centre demand.



